Smith Report

Definition and Overview

The Smith Report, published in 2003 under the stewardship of Sir Robert Smith, was a detailed examination of the roles and responsibilities of audit committees within public companies. Released concurrently with the Higgs Report on non-executive directors, the Smith Report provided extensive guidelines to improve corporate governance and enhance the monitoring of financial reporting and audit procedures.

The key objectives of the Smith Report included:

Strengthening the role of audit committees.
Enhancing the clarity of responsibilities and the scope of audit committees.
Boosting the protection of shareholders through accurate and reliable financial statements.

Both the Smith and Higgs Reports prompted crucial amendments to the UK’s Corporate Governance Code, emphasizing the accountability and effectiveness of audit committees and non-executive directors.

Examples

Example 1: A large corporation implements the Smith Report’s recommendations by ensuring that its audit committee is composed solely of independent non-executive directors who meet regularly to review financial statements and audit findings.
Example 2: A multinational publicly traded company enhances its internal audit procedures based on the Smith Report guidelines and conducts an external auditor review to ensure compliance with the revised Corporate Governance Code.
Example 3: A financial institution revises its audit committee charter in accordance with the Smith Report to clearly define the responsibilities, such as overseeing the risk management processes and the internal control environment.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the primary focus of the Smith Report?

The primary focus of the Smith Report is to provide comprehensive guidelines for the role, responsibilities, and objectives of audit committees in improving corporate governance and ensuring the reliability of financial reporting.

How does the Smith Report relate to the Higgs Report?

The Smith Report was published simultaneously with the Higgs Report, which focused on the role of non-executive directors. Together, these reports aimed to bolster corporate governance and were instrumental in revising the UK’s Corporate Governance Code.

What changes did the Smith Report bring to audit committees?

The Smith Report enhanced the accountability and effectiveness of audit committees by clearly defining their responsibilities, such as overseeing the financial reporting process, engaging with external auditors, and ensuring robust internal controls.

Who was Sir Robert Smith?

Sir Robert Smith chaired the committee that produced the Smith Report, guiding the examination of audit committee roles and driving the formulation of enhanced governance practices for listed companies.

What is the Corporate Governance Code?

The Corporate Governance Code, influenced by reports like the Smith and Higgs Reports, is a framework that provides principles and provisions for good corporate governance practices within listed companies in the UK.

Audit Committees: Committees within a board of directors responsible for overseeing the financial reporting process, audit procedures, and internal controls.
Higgs Report: A report on the role and effectiveness of non-executive directors, published in 2003 and contemporaneous with the Smith Report.
Corporate Governance Code: A set of principles and guidelines promoting effective governance, accountability, and compliance in publicly traded companies.

Online References

Suggested Books for Further Studies

“Corporate Governance” by Christine A. Mallin Explore comprehensive insights on corporate governance practices and the development influenced by reports such as the Smith and Higgs Reports.
“Financial Reporting and Corporate Governance” by Thomas A. Lee A critical examination of financial reporting standards and their intersection with corporate governance regulations.
“Corporate Governance: Principles, Policies, and Practices” by Bob Tricker An in-depth guide on corporate governance principles, including the evolution of audit committee roles post the Smith Report.

Accounting Basics: “Smith Report” Fundamentals Quiz

### What year was the Smith Report published? - [ ] 2001 - [ ] 2002 - [x] 2003 - [ ] 2004 > **Explanation:** The Smith Report was published in 2003 alongside the Higgs Report. ### Who chaired the committee responsible for the Smith Report? - [x] Sir Robert Smith - [ ] Sir David Tweedie - [ ] Lady Mary Peters - [ ] Sir Adrian Cadbury > **Explanation:** Sir Robert Smith chaired the committee that produced the Smith Report. ### What area does the Smith Report primarily address? - [ ] Employee benefits - [x] Audit committees - [ ] Tax compliance - [ ] Market regulations > **Explanation:** The report primarily focuses on the roles and responsibilities of audit committees within corporations. ### How did the Smith Report impact the Corporate Governance Code? - [x] It brought about critical revisions to the Code. - [ ] It led to the elimination of the Code. - [ ] It was unrelated to the Code. - [ ] It replaced the Code. > **Explanation:** The findings from the Smith Report were incorporated into revisions of the Corporate Governance Code, improving overall governance practices. ### Which other report was published simultaneously with the Smith Report? - [ ] Cadbury Report - [ ] Greenbury Report - [x] Higgs Report - [ ] King Report > **Explanation:** The Higgs Report on the role of non-executive directors was published alongside the Smith Report. ### What is the main goal of audit committees according to the Smith Report? - [ ] To calculate corporate taxes - [x] To ensure accurate and reliable financial reporting - [ ] To manage employee relations - [ ] To oversee marketing strategies > **Explanation:** The primary role of audit committees, as emphasized in the Smith Report, is to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the company’s financial reporting. ### The Smith Report places significant emphasis on which aspect of audit committees? - [ ] Increasing their size - [ ] Reducing their responsibilities - [x] Enhancing their accountability and effectiveness - [ ] Diversifying their roles to include marketing > **Explanation:** The Smith Report aimed to enhance the accountability and effectiveness of audit committees in overseeing financial reporting and audits. ### Which committee role is strengthened by the Smith Report recommendations? - [x] Audit Committees - [ ] Human Resources Committees - [ ] Marketing Committees - [ ] Investment Committees > **Explanation:** The recommendations specifically aim to strengthen audit committees. ### According to the Smith Report, who should comprise the audit committee? - [ ] Executive directors only - [x] Independent non-executive directors - [ ] Internal audit staff - [ ] Financial analysts > **Explanation:** It is recommended that the audit committee comprises independent non-executive directors to maintain objectivity and integrity. ### Which organization's principles were influenced by the Smith Report? - [ ] International Monetary Fund (IMF) - [ ] The World Bank - [ ] Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) - [x] Financial Reporting Council (FRC) > **Explanation:** The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) integrated the recommendations and principles from the Smith Report into their governance codes.

Thank you for embarking on this journey through our comprehensive accounting lexicon and tackling our challenging sample exam quiz questions. Keep striving for excellence in your financial knowledge!