Definition
Inchoate refers to actions or criminal offenses that are not yet fully completed or fully developed. In criminal law, inchoate offenses are those wherein the perpetrator has not successfully completed the intended crime but has taken substantial steps towards committing it.
Examples of Inchoate Offenses
-
Attempt: When an individual takes significant steps towards committing a crime but fails to complete it. For instance, attempting to rob a bank but being apprehended before any money is taken.
-
Conspiracy: When two or more individuals agree to commit a crime and take some steps to further that agreement. For example, planning a burglary and purchasing the necessary tools.
-
Solicitation: When an individual encourages, requests, or commands another person to commit a crime. For instance, hiring someone to commit a murder.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What differentiates inchoate offenses from completed offenses?
Inchoate offenses involve steps taken towards committing a crime, but the crime itself is not successfully completed, whereas completed offenses involve the completion of the criminal act.
Are inchoate offenses punishable by law?
Yes, inchoate offenses are punishable by law as they pose a serious intent to commit a crime and involve actions taken towards its execution. The penalties may vary depending on the jurisdiction.
Can a person be charged with both an inchoate offense and the completed crime?
Generally, a person cannot be charged with both an inchoate offense and the completed crime for the same act. If the crime is successfully completed, the perpetrator will likely be charged with the completed crime instead of the inchoate offense.
Do all jurisdictions treat inchoate offenses the same way?
No, the treatment of inchoate offenses can vary significantly by jurisdiction. Different states and countries have their own legal frameworks and penalties for inchoate offenses.
What is an example of an act that would be considered ‘attempted’ but not completed?
An example would be attempting to rob a store but being caught by the police before any property is stolen.
- Actus Reus: The physical act of committing a crime.
- Mens Rea: The mental intent to commit a crime.
- Accessory: A person who assists in the commission of a crime, but does not actually participate in the crime.
- Principal: The main perpetrator of a crime.
- Accomplice: A person who actively participates in the commission of a crime, generally alongside the principal.
Online References to Online Resources
Suggested Books for Further Studies
-
“Criminal Law” by Joel Samaha
An in-depth textbook that covers various aspects of criminal law, including inchoate offenses.
-
“Cases and Materials on Criminal Law” by Joshua Dressler
A comprehensive collection of case studies and materials relevant to criminal law topics, including inchoate offenses.
-
“The Oxford Handbook of Criminal Law” edited by Markus Dirk Dubber and Tatjana Hörnle
This handbook offers a deep dive into the foundational principles and contemporary issues in criminal law, including a valuable section on inchoate offenses.
Fundamentals of Inchoate Offenses: Criminal Law Basics Quiz
### What is an inchoate offense?
- [x] A crime that is not completed.
- [ ] A crime that is committed in secrecy.
- [ ] A crime that results in no harm.
- [ ] A crime conducted overseas.
> **Explanation:** An inchoate offense is a crime that is not completed but involves steps towards its commission.
### Which of the following is considered an inchoate offense?
- [x] Attempt
- [ ] Theft
- [ ] Arson
- [ ] Assault
> **Explanation:** Attempt is considered an inchoate offense because it involves actions taken towards committing a crime, but the crime is not completed.
### What do criminal laws typically seek to punish in inchoate offenses?
- [ ] The act itself
- [x] The intent and steps towards the crime
- [ ] The outcome of the crime
- [ ] The location of the crime
> **Explanation:** Criminal laws typically punish the intent and the steps taken towards committing a crime in inchoate offenses.
### What is an example of solicitation in the context of inchoate offenses?
- [x] Encouraging someone to commit murder.
- [ ] Attempting to rob a store.
- [ ] Planning to bribe an official.
- [ ] Committing arson.
> **Explanation:** Solicitation involves encouraging, requesting, or commanding someone to commit a crime, such as encouraging someone to commit murder.
### What must be present for an attempt to be considered an inchoate offense?
- [ ] Physical injury
- [ ] Financial loss
- [x] Significant steps towards the crime
- [ ] Property damage
> **Explanation:** Significant steps towards committing the crime must be present for an attempt to be considered an inchoate offense.
### Who can be prosecuted for a conspiracy offense?
- [x] Two or more individuals
- [ ] Only one individual
- [ ] A minor acting alone
- [ ] Only government officials
> **Explanation:** For a conspiracy offense, there must be two or more individuals who agree to commit a crime and take steps to further that agreement.
### Under which circumstance can an individual be charged with an inchoate crime even if the crime was not completed?
- [x] When there was an attempt to commit the crime
- [ ] When the person changes their mind before acting
- [ ] When the crime plan was only discussed but no action taken
- [ ] When no specific plan was in place
> **Explanation:** An individual can be charged with an inchoate crime when there was an attempt to commit the crime, involving significant steps towards its commission.
### What is the primary difference between an accessory and an accomplice?
- [ ] An accomplice assists before the crime, an accessory after
- [ ] An accessory is present during the crime, an accomplice isn't
- [x] An accessory assists after the crime, an accomplice during
- [ ] An accomplice plans the crime, an accessory executes it
> **Explanation:** An accomplice actively participates during the commission of a crime, while an accessory assists after the crime has been committed.
### Which legal concept focuses on the intent of an individual to commit a crime?
- [x] Mens Rea
- [ ] Actus Reus
- [ ] Habeas Corpus
- [ ] Stare Decisis
> **Explanation:** Mens Rea refers to the mental intent of an individual to commit a crime, which is crucial in establishing liability in criminal law.
### What kind of actions are required for a charge of conspiracy?
- [x] An agreement and an overt act to further the crime
- [ ] Direct participation in the crime only
- [ ] Witnessing but not reporting the crime
- [ ] None, only knowledge of the crime
> **Explanation:** For a charge of conspiracy, there must be an agreement between two or more individuals and an overt act that further facilitates the commitment of the crime.
Thank you for exploring the concept of inchoate offenses in criminal law and engaging with the quiz to test and enhance your understanding.
