General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR)

General Anti-Abuse Rule GAAR Tax Avoidance Tax Law UK Taxation Finance Act 2013 Tax Advantage Direct Taxation
A measure designed to counter tax avoidance in the UK by outlawing any arrangement that creates a tax advantage through means judged 'artificial and abusive.' The rule evaluates the reasonableness of the arrangements.
On this page

Definition

The General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR) is a provision within UK law aimed at countering tax avoidance by targeting arrangements that generate a tax advantage through means deemed to be “artificial and abusive.” The reasonableness test involves assessing whether it would be logical for someone to enter the arrangements without considering tax reduction as the main objective. GAAR applies to all principal forms of direct taxation, including inheritance tax, and was implemented following the royal assent to the Finance Act 2013. It is not retroactively applicable to arrangements established before this date.

Examples

Example 1: Artificial Income Shifting

A taxpayer sets up a complex web of inter-company transactions and shell companies solely designed to shift income to jurisdictions with lower tax rates, thus significantly reducing their tax liability in the UK. Under GAAR, these arrangements may be assessed and declared abusive, disallowing the tax advantage claimed.

Example 2: Exploiting Loopholes in Gift Regulations

An individual gifts substantial assets to family members using intricate contractual arrangements that do not reflect genuine gifting intentions but aim specifically to reduce inheritance tax. GAAR can be invoked to challenge and undo these arrangements if judged artificial and abusive.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the main objective of GAAR?

The principal aim of GAAR is to prevent tax avoidance strategies that exploit legal loopholes and arrangements deemed not commercially viable or are primarily designed to obtain tax advantages.

How does GAAR differ from specific anti-abuse rules?

Unlike specific anti-abuse rules that target particular tax avoidance schemes, GAAR is a broad measure that addresses any arrangement considered artificial and abusive across various tax domains.

Can GAAR be applied retroactively?

No, GAAR cannot be applied to arrangements established before the enactment of the Finance Act 2013. It only affects transactions and arrangements entered into after the royal assent.

What is considered ‘artificial and abusive’?

An arrangement is regarded as ‘artificial and abusive’ if it is created mainly to produce a tax advantage rather than having a genuine commercial purpose.

Who decides if an arrangement is abusive?

The decision is usually made based on the GAAR Advisory Panel’s assessment, which evaluates the reasonableness and commercial substance of the arrangements.

  • Tax Avoidance: Legally exploiting the tax system to reduce current or future tax liabilities.
  • Tax Evasion: Illegal practices to avoid taxes, such as not reporting income.
  • Finance Act 2013: UK legislation introducing GAAR and other fiscal measures.
  • Inheritance Tax: A tax on the estate of the deceased, including property, money, and possessions.

Online References

  1. UK Government - Overview of GAAR
  2. HM Revenue & Customs - GAAR Guidance
  3. Finance Act 2013 Full Text

Suggested Books for Further Studies

  1. “UK Tax System: An Introduction” by Malcolm James
  2. “Tax Avoidance Law in the UK” by Philip Baker
  3. “Tolley’s Tax Planning” by Rebecca Benneyworth

Accounting Basics: “General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR)” Fundamentals Quiz

### What is the primary purpose of the General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR)? - [ ] To simplify tax laws - [ ] To reduce corporate tax rates - [ x ] To counteract tax avoidance through artificial and abusive arrangements - [ ] To harmonize tax rates across Europe > **Explanation:** The primary purpose of GAAR is to counteract tax avoidance by targeting arrangements that are judged to be artificial and abusive. ### When did the General Anti-Abuse Rule come into effect? - [ ] January 1, 2009 - [ ] April 1, 2011 - [x] Royal assent to the Finance Act 2013 - [ ] December 31, 2015 > **Explanation:** The GAAR came into effect upon the royal assent to the Finance Act 2013. ### Can GAAR be applied retroactively to arrangements established before the Finance Act 2013? - [ ] Yes - [x] No - [ ] Sometimes - [ ] Only to arrangements within the fiscal year > **Explanation:** GAAR cannot be applied to any arrangements entered into before the enactment of the Finance Act 2013. ### Which of the following taxes are impacted by GAAR? - [ ] Only income tax - [ ] Only corporate tax - [x] All main forms of direct taxation, including inheritance tax - [ ] Only VAT > **Explanation:** GAAR applies to all main forms of direct taxation, including inheritance tax. ### What is used to assess if the tax arrangements are abusive under GAAR? - [ ] The opinion of the taxpayer - [ ] Historical tax data - [x] A reasonableness test - [ ] The frequency of tax audits > **Explanation:** A reasonableness test is used to assess whether the arrangements would make sense beyond just obtaining a tax advantage. ### Who gives the final judgment on whether an arrangement is 'artificial and abusive' under GAAR? - [ ] The taxpayer's accountant - [ ] The tax tribunals - [ ] The local tax office - [x] The GAAR Advisory Panel > **Explanation:** The GAAR Advisory Panel evaluates and provides the final judgment on the nature of the arrangements. ### What distinguishes GAAR from other anti-abuse tax rules? - [ ] It focuses on indirect taxation - [ ] It is less stringent - [x] It has a broader scope covering various abusive arrangements - [ ] It only applies to multinational corporations > **Explanation:** GAAR has a broader scope as it covers various types of abusive tax arrangements, unlike specific anti-abuse rules. ### What kind of arrangements does GAAR specifically target? - [ ] Simple tax-deductible expenses - [x] Arrangements that are artificial and primarily aimed at obtaining a tax advantage - [ ] Legitimate business expenses - [ ] Personal expense claims > **Explanation:** GAAR targets arrangements that are considered artificial and primarily aimed at obtaining a tax advantage. ### Under GAAR, what is an arrangement judged against to determine if it is abusive? - [ ] Historical precedent - [ ] The financial interest of the taxpayer - [x] The concept of reasonableness and commercial substance - [ ] The length of time it takes to execute the arrangement > **Explanation:** An arrangement is judged against the concept of reasonableness and whether it has genuine commercial substance. ### Which Act introduced GAAR into the UK legislation? - [ ] Finance Act 2006 - [x] Finance Act 2013 - [ ] Companies Act 2006 - [ ] Anti-Avoidance Act 2008 > **Explanation:** GAAR was introduced into UK legislation by the Finance Act 2013.

Thank you for diving into the intricacies of the General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR) and sharpening your understanding through our challenging quizzes. Keep enhancing your knowledge of UK taxation!

Tuesday, August 6, 2024
General Commissioners (UK)
General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR)
General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR) January 1, 1
Anti-Avoidance Provisions January 1, 1
Assignment of Income January 1, 1
Tax Avoidance January 1, 1
Tax Evasion January 1, 1
Westminster Doctrine January 1, 1

Accounting Terms Lexicon

Discover comprehensive accounting definitions and practical insights. Empowering students and professionals with clear and concise explanations for a better understanding of financial terms.